Friday, December 1, 2017

On the Dissonance of Waiting

I sat in Starbucks today, reading my newest book, waiting for my tutoring student to show up.  A little early for what I thought was our 3:30 appointment, I checked the clock at periodic intervals.  Sometimes she ran a little late, so when 3:30 came and went, I didn’t worry too much.  But after finishing another chapter, I checked my phone again and saw it was almost 3:45.  Should I text her?  I wondered.  She isn’t usually this late.  I hope she’s okay.  After hemming and hawing about what to do, I picked up my phone to text her.  It was then that I remembered: although our normal time was 3:30, we had agreed on a 4:00 meeting time for today.  Exhaling, glad there wasn’t a scary reason for her delay, I picked up my book again.  She showed up at 4:03.

This is the exact kind of story that people use when they are trying to tell someone who is waiting for something—and who has been waiting for a long time—why they shouldn’t despair.  I know it’s so hard to wait, they say.  But keep your chin up.  Everything will turn out okay in the end.  Timing is so important.  These anecdotes—usually well-intentioned and meant to be supportive—can be helpful.  Being reminded that our human stories can end happily, that the nervewracking middle portion of the story is just a warm up for the satisfying ending, gives us hope.

But there are times when these stories are infuriating.  Because sometimes the ending that we hope for never comes.  Or it feels like someone else in our lives gets our perfect ending.  Or one of our storylines comes to an unexpected, not necessarily unwelcome, conclusion and we fail to appreciate it because we were looking for something entirely different.  Stories are one of our greatest weapons in trying to understand being human, and the collective stories we tell create that “Me, too!” moment that I believe powerfully bonds us together as few things can.  But—and this is hard for me to admit—stories can do so much damage to our ability to see reality for what it is and to appreciate the unique paths that our lives take.  When we begin to apply others’ stories, real or fictional, to our own, we lose sight of what’s in front of us—what’s real.

How do we balance this?  The hope and the reality (both our own realities and the realities of others)?  The hopes that we all have for certain things, those castles we build in the sky when we are young, are a source of fuel as we venture out on the path that we desire to follow.  Once we pick a place to set up camp and as we begin to build in earnest, on land this time, we come to know more about the soil, the climate, the resources, and the people who populate the land on which we’ve chosen to build, and the reality can create dissonance with the dreams we once had.  Dissonance can be beautiful—just ask any musician.  But there’s still something not quite right about it.  It’s unsettling.  And how do we know the difference between dissonance that is supposed to be a part of the musical score and dissonance that comes from hitting a wrong note?

There was a week in June when half of my stuff was here in my storage unit in Michigan and the other half was still at my apartment in Fort Wayne.  I was staying at my parents’ for the week so I could start work, a job I had lined up a few months before moving back—a repeat employer.  One of the million items on my moving To-Do list was researching insurance.  A friend had recommended someone she knew at a large local insurance company and I made an appointment.  (I’ll leave them nameless—not because they did anything heinous, just because it feels like the classier move.)  Five minutes into my appointment with the representative my friend had referred, he stopped the meeting and said, “Can I ask you something random?”  He was married, so I figured it wasn’t going to be an awkward date invite.  I said, “Sure.”

“Have you ever thought about doing this?” he asked.  “Um, selling insurance?” I said.  “Yeah, you’ve got such a friendly personality and high energy.  I think you’d be great at it.  Can I give you a five minute pitch for our company?”  I told him he could, and, despite not selling me insurance that day, he sold his company well enough to get me to agree to speak with a recruiter.

“This isn’t my plan,” I told myself as I walked out of the building with both insurance information and a possible new career path, “but maybe it’s what I’ve been waiting for!”

For the next month (yes, month), I followed all the steps involved in the interview process.  There was an essay I had to write, a four-hour seminar I had to attend, multiple phone and in-person interviews I had to survive, and informational surveys I had to give to people I both knew and did not know (to see if I was capable of talking to strangers about insurance).  But the activity that gave me the most to think about was the list of 200 people I had to make.

For the company to determine whether my market was any good or not, I had to list the first 200 people I would call if I got the job.  These were supposed to be the people who would give me referrals because they know I’m a trustworthy person or people who might need some insurance help themselves.  Not only did I have to list each person’s name and contact information, but I had to include his or her job title, where they work, their age bracket, how I know them, their estimated salary, and what the strength of the relationship was.  I procrastinated on this task and had to do it all in one day—and it took me the whole day to complete.  The nerdy part of me found it interesting to see all of my people broken down into these different categories.  But the “strength of relationship” column was the hardest for me.  I’m one of those people who sees everyone I know as a pretty good friend.  Having to choose a number from 1 to 5 to classify each person felt hard.

It was filling out this chart that made me so aware of why this wasn’t the job for me: I wasn’t interested in making my relationships mercenary.  I didn’t want to be that person whose name popped up on a friend’s caller ID, only to have them silence my call, afraid that I was calling for more referrals.  I didn’t want to see every person I met, from there on out, as a potential client.  Doing this activity helped me see that choosing that job would have been a misstep for me, an I-hit-the-wrong-note kind of dissonance.  So I turned the job down.

In many ways, insurance would have been the easy answer to the questions that have been pressing on me since July 2016, when I knew for sure that I was going to quit my teaching job at the end of the 2016-2017 school year.  My constant companions since have included (but are not limited to) the following questions: What’s next?  If not teaching, what?  If this plan I made when I was 18 years old isn’t the path I want to keep following, how do I go about finding a new path?  How am I going to make money?  What if I never find a job I like?  How do I find a sugar daddy so I can look pretty at parties and make cupcakes for a living?  (I kid, I kid.)

Questions like these—the ones that center around what form our lives will take—create dissonance.  They do in mine, at least.  They are jarring and heavy and all-consuming.  They are unsettling.  And work isn’t the only topic of those questions, although that’s been my primary source of dissonance since the day I graduated.  The questions that haunt adults are many in number.  And always that core question: is this dissonance, this natural dissonance that comes with adult life, is it because I’m playing the wrong note or is it because that’s how it’s supposed to be?

What I’m finding out is that the What-Kind-of-Dissonance-Is-It Game is closely connected to becoming comfortable with waiting.  Time is the only indicator of whether a choice we make is a wrong note or if it’s a blend of gorgeous, unsettling dissonance.  Sometimes, we get that time cushion before we make a definite choice, as I did with my job interview last summer.  But sometimes we make the best choice based on the information in front of us and we wait to see what happens.  Either way, waiting is the only way to know.

Except I’m totally and completely and 100% not okay with waiting.  Rome wasn’t built in a day; we just have to play the waiting game; if at first you don’t succeed, try, try again…blah blah blah.  All of this feels like petty BS as I find myself again—of my own making—in a situation where I’ve quit my job and need to find a new one.  I’ve done this so many times in my adult life that I’m beginning to worry I will keep doing it because it’s normal.

This time feels different, though—a conclusion I’ve been able to reach, in part, because of the generosity of a friend who offered me free rent at a safe place where I can sort through all I’ve done so far in my adult life and make a clear decision about what is next.  In the five months since I’ve moved home to Michigan, I can see, looking back, that I’ve taken the most highly functional route I could find when I’ve completely upended my work life in the past.  I mean, let’s be real: the last time I quit my teaching job because I was overworked and cried every day, I started my own business.  I went straight from one stressful thing to another, without giving myself any leeway to do what I’ve been doing since July: take stock of what’s here, gather up what I’ve learned, make choices thoughtfully.

(Note: None of that is to say that starting my own business was the wrong choice or a thoughtless choice.  I’m incredibly proud of my LLC and the fact that I lived off of it for three years.  It’s just not a storyline I want to repeat at this juncture.)

I’ve been that drowning person who is flailing about, using up all my energy in an attempt to stay afloat, not realizing that the secret to floating is to lay back and stare at the sky.  But not this time.  This time, I’m waiting.  I’m laying back and staring at the sky.  I’m refusing to check my phone every three minutes as I wait at a Starbucks.  Oh, I’m working, too.  I’ve got four jobs right now, all situations that have showed up at just the right times (thanks, God!).  For those nice, compact storylines, I am thankful.

But as I float and stare at the sky, I’m also thinking about all the things I’ve learned along the way—about myself, about work, about adult life, about what makes me tick—and I’m taking stock of those tools and resources that will help me build my best life brick by brick.  This transition from Indiana back to Michigan has been more challenging than I expected, and I chalk that up to taking a different approach than the ones I’ve previously tried.  But Rome wasn’t built in a day.  I suppose my life (and yours) won’t be, either.

Wednesday, November 22, 2017

Mixed Tape

I want to bring back the days where song lyrics were an acceptable form of communication.  When I was in college, my IM Away Messages saw their fair share of passive-aggressive lyrical zingers, but that’s not what I’m talking about.  Down with those veiled references we hoped would come across clearly to the specific person we were aiming at!  Ain’t nobody got time for that.  I mean using song lyrics in the same way that people used to use great poetry: to amuse, to seduce, to flatter, to appreciate the flow of words.  To allow the professionals to say something that coming from a regular person might sound ridiculous.

Do the kids these days make anything that is the equivalent of a mixed tape?  Is there a 21st century version of standing outside Diane Court’s bedroom window with a boombox over your head?  I want to return to a Lloyd Dobler-esque use of music—letting those words speak for you when you feel you cannot.  (And if that classic movie reference is lost on you, find yourself Say Anything and watch.  It has one of the most romantic uses of music of just about any movie I’ve ever seen.)

If you’re watching The Voice this season, you’ll know there is a girl from Fort Wayne who is really making her mark.  She goes to the high school at which I previously worked, and while I never had her in class, there’s a little part of me that feels connected to her.  This week, she sang a song from the musical Waitress which has lyrics I love:

It's not simple to say
That most days I don't recognize me
That these shoes and this apron
That place and its patrons
Have taken more than I gave them
It's not easy to know
I'm not anything like I used to be
Although it's true
I was never attention's sweet center
I still remember that girl

She's imperfect but she tries
She is good but she lies
She is hard on herself
She is broken and won't ask for help
She is messy but she's kind
She is lonely most of the time
She is all of this mixed up
And baked in a beautiful pie
She is gone but she used to be mine

It's not what I asked for
Sometimes life just slips in through a back door
And carves out a person
And makes you believe it's all true
And now I've got you
And you're not what I asked for
If I'm honest I know I would give it all back
For a chance to start over
And rewrite an ending or two
For the girl that I knew

Who'll be reckless just enough
Who'll get hurt but
Who learns how to toughen up when she's bruised
And gets used by a man who can't love
And then she'll get stuck and be scared
Of the life that's inside her
Growing stronger each day
'Til it finally reminds her
To fight just a little
To bring back the fire in her eyes
That's been gone but it used to be mine

She is messy but she's kind
She is lonely most of the time
She is all of this mixed up and baked in a beautiful pie
She is gone but she used to be mine
(“She Used to Be Mine”, Sara Bareilles)

Hearing Addison sing that on Monday made me think about other song lyrics that move me the way these do.  So, I would like to take a second during this week of thankfulness to be thankful for words by sharing some lyrics that I love.  My mixed tape, if you will.  These are songs that bring me peace and comfort and “me, too!” moments that are so necessary to coping with the day-to-day.  Here are just a few lines from songs, new and old, that, when I hear them, make me go “Yep—that’s being human.”  (And I’ve included who wrote them, of course—the former English teacher cannot be guilty of plagiarism by not giving credit where it is due!)

Please feel free to share favorite songs or song lyrics!  Spreading the word love is always acceptable here.  Enjoy!

“But if you’re too proud to follow rivers
How you ever gonna find the sea?”
(“River”, Emeli Sande)

“I want to live with you, even when we’re ghosts.”
(“Say You Won’t Let Go”, James Arthur, lyrics by James Arthur, Neil Ormandy, Steve Solomon)

“Oh, where do we begin?  The rubble or our sins?”
(“Pompeii”, Bastille, lyrics by Dan Smith)

“But I’ve read this script and the costume fit
So I played my part.”
(“Cleopatra”, The Lumineers, lyrics by Wesley Schultz, Jeremiah Fraites, Simone Felice)

“You told me something that scared me to death
Don’t take me home, I can’t face that yet
I’m ashamed that I’m barely human
And I’m ashamed that I don’t have a heart you can break
I’m just action and at other times reaction.”
(“Nothing to Remember”, Neko Case)

“I am 32 flavors and then some.”
(“32 Flavors”, Ani DiFranco)

“What if the silence let you dream?
What if the air could let you breathe?
What if the words would bring you here?
What if this sound could bring you peace?
What if what is isn’t true?
What are you going to do?”
(“Appels + Oranjes”, The Smashing Pumpkins, lyrics by Billy Corgan)

“Unravel me
Untie this cord
The very center of our union is caving in
I can’t endure
I am the archive of our failure
And all I feel is black and white
And I’m wound up small and tight
And I don’t know who I am.”
(“Black and White”, Sarah McLachlan)

“We have found our hope
We have found our peace
We have found our rest
In the One Who loves.”
(“The One Who Saves”, Hillsong, lyrics by Ben Fielding)

“It’s got what it takes
So tell me why can’t this be love?
Straight from my heart
Oh, tell me why can’t this be love?
I tell myself:
Hey, only fools rush in
And only time will tell if we stand the test of time
All I know
You’ve got to run to win
And I’ll be damned if I’ll get hung up on the line.”
(“Why Can’t This Be Love”, Van Halen, lyrics by Eddie Van Halen, Michael Anthony, Sammy Hagar, Alex Van Halen)

“I wanna wake up where you are.”
(“Slide”, Goo Goo Dolls, lyrics by John Rzeznik)

“The skin of my emotion lies beneath my own.”
(“Never Is a Promise”, Fiona Apple)

“When your heart’s on fire
You must realize
Smoke gets in your eyes.”
(“Smoke Gets in Your Eyes”, The Platters, lyrics by Otto Harbach)

“She’s just a girl and she’s on fire
Hotter than a fantasy,
Lonely like a highway.”
(“Girl on Fire”, Alicia Keys, lyrics by Alicia Keys, Billy Squier, Jeff Bhasker)

“Lovin’ you was sort of like loving a fifth of the finest bourbon
Was it your quality or high quantity that’s put me in the shape that I’m in?”
(“Can’t Stop Thinking ‘Bout You”, Martin Sexton)

“There a stranger speaks outside her door
Says take what you can from your dreams
Make them as real as anything
It’d take the work out of the courage.”
(“Grey Street”, Dave Matthews Band, lyrics by Dave Matthews)

“Too long I’ve been afraid of losing love I guess I’ve lost,
Well, if that’s love—it comes at much too high a cost
I’d sooner buy defying gravity.”
(“Defying Gravity”, from Wicked, lyrics by Stephen Schwartz)

Sunday, November 19, 2017

On Running and Tradition

I’ve been a runner since I was 14 years old.  I joined cross country partially because my brother was on the team and partially because my mom said it would be easier if she only had to drive us one place for practices.  The only other fall sports option for girls at my high school was basketball, and, as a mediocre middle school basketball player (at best), I knew that I wasn’t interested in subjecting myself to the humiliation that would have resulted from trying out for the team.  So, I ran.

I had never been a runner before, but I’ve always been one of those people who assumes they’ll be fine when the important moments happen, even if the preparation leading up to those important moments has indicated otherwise.  I did the same thing with cross country: sure, my sporadic running during the summer had been tough, and, sure, I couldn’t manage a practice run without extensive walking.  But—meh—I would be fine whenever the races rolled around.

In my first 5K (3.1 mile) race, I clocked an impressive time, somewhere in the ballpark of 47 minutes, if I’m remembering correctly.  For those of you not quick on the mental math, this works out to over 15 minutes per mile.  In college, I was out on a date with a guy who had also been a high school runner, and after regaling him with this story, he asked me tentatively, “Not trying to be a jerk, but did you sit down to rest?”  I can remember the course vividly—probably because I was going through it so slowly that details had the chance to sink in—and as I walked past various cones and course markers, wondering when the finish line would appear, I can remember thinking, “Okay, maybe I need to try a little harder in practices.”

And so I did.  I took the advice of an upperclassman guy who told me: “Never walk.  You could be running slower than you’ve ever run before, but it doesn’t matter.  Just don’t walk.”  I pushed myself hard that year, and by the end of the season, I was awarded both the “Most Improved” award and the “Most Valuable” award.  My other three high school seasons were successful in their own rights, but nothing ever topped the feeling of that season for me—knowing I had changed so drastically within a few months through hard work and mental toughness.  I was addicted from there on out.  Running has been something I’ve done and a runner is something I’ve been ever since.

Running is an outlet for me, one to which I always return, even when I’ve taken a break from it, and it’s an activity that centers me, a ritual that provides a respite from the chaos and upheaval of everyday life.  I run to running when I feel like I can’t cope, and hearing the regular pattern of my feet hitting the ground, coupled with the in-and-out of my breathing, is a bit like meditation for me.  In my day-to-day life, I rarely stop thinking.  But when I run?  It’s the closest I get to clearing my mind.

I would be lying if I said that part of why I run isn’t also because it keeps me in the shape I like to be in.  Going out for a run tends to tell me everything I need to know about my current level of fitness.  Typically, even in my worst shape, I can still gut out a 5K.  If I can’t make it those 3.1 miles, I know that I’ve fallen pretty far.  And I don’t say that to suggest that people who can’t run 3.1 miles are woefully out of shape—that’s just a test that I use to gauge where I am at in terms of my body and my muscles and my weight.  I would guess that everyone has their own test they use, and a 5K is mine.

These are all typical reasons for sticking with running, and they are reasons I hear from other friends who run.  But there is one other reason that I personally still cling to my 20-year running habit: tradition.

As a 30-something person who is single and has no children, one of the things I’ve noticed is the change in how I view traditions, particularly holiday traditions.  The traditions we follow as children are set up by our parents, and we stick closely to those until life circumstances help us to create new ones.  Often those new traditions come from marrying into a family that has its own ways of doing the holidays or other special days, or they develop as a result of parenthood.  A challenge for me has been watching my childhood traditions fade away without feeling like I have new ones to replace them.  Once my grandma moved out of her home into assisted living and my brother’s and cousins’ families grew to such a place where it wasn’t feasible to be together for the holidays, those big days I looked forward to as a child and as a teenager lost some of their shine.  I don’t begrudge my family those choices—part of being married and having a family means making decisions about how to best spend the limited time during these busy seasons.  But I have struggled with feeling sad during the holidays because of the loss of old traditions, and this has led me to seek out ways to create new traditions for myself.

Running has given me a foundation upon which to build these traditions.  On Easter, I go to the sunrise service at my church and then I do a long morning run on my favorite trail.  Usually New Year’s Day sees me on a morning run, too, giving me time to think about all I’d like to accomplish in the next year as the cold air kisses my face.  Those are both unofficial rituals—ones I experience alone, but ones that I prioritize, nonetheless.  However, on Thanksgiving I take part in a tradition that I look forward to all year: the Detroit Turkey Trot.  It’s a huge race, so I’m certainly not alone in this early-morning endeavor, and it makes for some great people watching.  Many groups come down in Christmas-themed costumes and the spectators on the side of the road, trying to get good seats for the Thanksgiving Parade that follows the race, make the atmosphere festive and lively.  There is music and laughter and “You can do it!”.  My own anticipation of this race usually starts in mid-October.  As the fall marches on toward winter, the prospect of running a 10K (6.2 miles) keeps me running regularly, even as the weather gets cold (which I prefer to run in, anyways), and on the actual day, I revel in knowing that I can eat whatever I want later because I’ve put in 6.2 miles before 9:00am.

The Turkey Trot has given me stories to tell—like the time I left my car key hanging on the back of a bathroom door in an out-of-the-way Detroit parking garage where, every year, I make a pit stop before going to the starting line.  The gun had gone off and I had just crossed the starting line when I realized my key wasn’t tied to my shoe, as it usually is.  I had a moment where the competitive side of me said from one shoulder: “It will still be there once you finish…no one knows about that bathroom.”  The practical side of me was having none of that, because from the other shoulder, I heard, “Karen Carson…this is your car…your actual car!  Go get your key!”.  I left the race, promising the race officials I would re-enter where I had exited, and ran to that parking garage bathroom, hoping my key would still be there.  It was—and I dutifully re-entered the race where I had exited, finishing with a time that satisfied my competitive side.

There’s the story about how I found that secret bathroom in the first place.  Suffice it to say, I learned my lesson about not eating cabbage soup the night before a race.  I firmly believe God answered my “I need a bathroom NOW” prayer, and hopefully that’s the last time I ever have to make a “when I poop my pants, here’s what I’ll do next” plan.  (And in case you’re concerned—it wasn’t a plan I had to implement.  Phew.)

One year, I got up and ran those 6.2 miles after spending the previous day in transit from England to Detroit following the wedding of one of my best college friends.  On Thanksgiving Eve, I took a taxi from my hotel in Norwich, England to the local train station; a train from that small English town into London; London’s Tube from King’s Cross to Heathrow Airport; a plane from London Heathrow to Chicago O’Hare; and my own car from O’Hare to my home in Detroit.  It was an obscene number of travel miles in a day—and I can remember posting on Facebook that early Thanksgiving morning: “What’s 6.2 miles more when you’ve traveled 4390.8 the day before?”  Jet lag hadn’t taken me quite yet, and I ran a solid race only to crash HARD later that day.

Running every Thanksgiving morning has meant connecting with friends.  Sometimes friends have also been running in the race or I’ve randomly encountered people I know while downtown.  Standing in the chute waiting to start, I’ve had pleasant chats with other people who are there doing the same thing I am—following tradition.  Last year, these two guys I had been talking with decided we should all run together, something I pretended to go along with to be polite, quickly losing them on the course so I could just run my race.  I am glad to be surrounded by so many other runners, but it’s the tradition with myself that gets me out of bed every year.

I wonder if other adults have traditions with themselves.  Not just things they do with their significant others or children, although those are important, but specific activities they do with and for themselves.  Events they look forward to every year.  Goings-on they anticipate in the same way they anticipated their childhood traditions.  I know that, for me, having traditions with myself has helped remind me that not all of adulthood has to be full of functioning.  It’s so easy to get caught up in the To-Do’s of life and, especially when life gets crazy (like at the holidays), to forget to make time for those things that make us happy for no reason other than “I do this every year.”  Even running—something that fills a quota or achieves a goal for many adults—can be something that is enjoyable for its own sake (something I plan to write more about this week).

I don’t run on Thanksgiving because it helps me maintain my weight or because I need to hit my quota of miles for that week.  I run on Thanksgiving because I want to and because the anticipation of this tradition is something that makes me excited about the life I’ve built for myself.  Perhaps that sounds dramatic, but I believe that’s what traditions do—they become building blocks for our lives and they are something we can depend on, even when things seem less-than-steady.


What are the traditions that anchor your world?  What traditions will you start (or continue) with yourself?  Think of me as I’m gutting out all 6.2 miles of my favorite tradition on Thursday.  I haven’t trained nearly as much as I would have liked and it probably won’t be my best time ever—but that isn’t the point of the tradition, is it?